Sugar City, Idaho Real Estate Market Report

or Create your own market report

Understanding the real estate market in Sugar City, Idaho starts with accurate, local data. This market report provides a real-time snapshot of home prices, sales activity, inventory levels, and overall market trends specific to Sugar City.

Why This Market Report Matters

If you’re buying or selling a home in Sugar City, timing and pricing are critical. Market conditions can shift quickly based on inventory, interest rates, seasonality, and buyer demand. This report helps remove uncertainty by showing what’s actually happening in the local market right now.

How to Use This Market Data

The interactive market report below allows you to:

  • Track median home prices and price trends
  • Review recent sales and average days on market
  • Monitor inventory levels and new listings
  • Compare list prices versus sold prices
  • Identify whether the market favors buyers or sellers

This data can help you price a home accurately, evaluate purchase timing, strengthen negotiations, and confirm whether broader market headlines apply to Sugar City specifically.

Current Sugar City Market Overview

This market report updates automatically using MLS data and reflects current conditions for:

  • Single-family homes
  • Condos and townhomes
  • New construction properties

Because Sugar City’s market dynamics can differ from nearby cities and county-wide averages, this report focuses solely on Sugar City-specific data so your decisions are based on relevant local trends.

How to Interpret the Numbers

  • Rising prices and low inventory often indicate a seller-leaning market
  • Stable prices and longer days on market suggest more balanced conditions
  • Increasing inventory may create additional negotiating power for buyers

Market statistics tell an important story, but individual properties are also influenced by location, condition, and local demand drivers.

Want a Property-Specific Analysis?

Market averages are helpful, but real estate decisions are best made using property-level data. If you’d like:

  • A personalized home value estimate
  • A neighborhood market breakdown
  • Guidance on how these trends affect your situation

Connect with a local Sugar City real estate expert at Real Estate Two70 for tailored insights and professional guidance.


This market report is for educational purposes and is updated regularly using MLS data. For advice related to a specific property, professional consultation is recommended.

Active Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
307 E 5th S 3 3 1,745 $470,000 $269 Unknown
532 Austin Ave 7 4 2,942 $515,000 $175 Unknown
396 Camas St 4 3 2,167 $569,995 $263 Unknown
2 Brandon Dr 3 2 1,429 $370,000 $258 Unknown
431 S Idaho Ave 3 2 1,485 $415,000 $279 Unknown
23 N Front St 3 2 1,560 $350,000 $224 Unknown
3679 N 5000 E 4 2 2,080 $350,000 $168 Unknown
370 Camas St 5 3 2,280 $579,999 $254 Unknown
274 W 4th S 4 3 1,807 $355,000 $196 Unknown
314 Poppy St 3 3 1,745 $470,000 $269 Unknown
294 W 4th S 4 3 1,807 $339,000 $187 Unknown
3442 E 2000 N 5 4 3,508 $569,995 $162 Unknown
455 S Blue Spruce Ave Unit #114 3 3 1,531 $334,900 $218 Unknown
455 S Blue Spruce Ave Unit #115 3 3 1,531 $334,900 $218 Unknown
458 S 3rd W Unit #458 3 3 1,604 $345,000 $215 Unknown
Average: 3.8 2.9 1,948 $424,585 $224 N/A day
Viewing 1 - 15 of 15
Viewing 1 - 15 of 15
Properties Under Contract
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
124 S Front St 3 1 1,056 $290,000 $274 Unknown
25 W 1st S 2 1 864 $250,000 $289 Unknown
346 E 5th S 4 2 1,905 $499,000 $261 Unknown
343 S Teton Ave 3 3 1,772 $414,900 $234 Unknown
276 Blue Sky Ct 4 3 1,807 $339,000 $187 Unknown
267 Blue Sky Ct 3 3 1,807 $339,000 $187 Unknown
288 E 5th S 5 3 2,200 $585,000 $265 Unknown
Average: 3.4 2.3 1,630 $388,128 $243 N/A day
Viewing 1 - 7 of 7
Viewing 1 - 7 of 7
Sold Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
202 W 3rd S 5 2 2,528 $415,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 8/31/26
119 Michelle Dr 5 3 3,124 $475,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 7/17/26
367 E 5th S 5 4 2,485 $584,900 N/A Unknown Unknown 7/10/26
2224 E Hwy 33 3 3 1,786 $429,900 N/A Unknown Unknown 7/9/26
126 W 3rd St S 3 2 1,764 $380,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 7/2/26
116 N Fremont Ave 5 4 3,106 $639,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 7/1/26
393 Camas St 3 2 1,430 $425,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 7/1/26
250 W 4th S 4 3 1,650 $433,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 6/29/26
545 S Cutler Ave 7 4 3,085 $519,900 N/A Unknown Unknown 6/12/26
4715 N 3000 E 3 3 2,694 $725,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 5/22/26
286 Camas St 4 2 1,905 $530,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 5/14/26
112 S Park Ave 3 2 1,860 $425,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 5/1/26
455 S Blue Spruce Ave Unit #116 3 3 1,531 $350,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 4/30/26
219 S Austin Ave 5 3 2,094 $390,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 4/23/26
No address 6 4 2,323 $650,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 4/22/26
2879 E 1000 N 4 2 3,512 $525,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 4/3/26
577 Furrow Dr 3 3 1,596 $299,900 N/A Unknown Unknown 4/1/26
505 Furrow Dr 3 3 1,596 $299,900 N/A Unknown Unknown 3/27/26
460 S Austin Ave 4 3 3,200 $529,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 3/17/26
669 Conveyor Ave 3 3 1,596 $309,900 N/A Unknown Unknown 3/5/26
3752 E Hwy 33 3 1 1,056 $325,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 2/18/26
24 Jaxon Dr 3 1 1,071 $267,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 2/13/26
343 Poppy St 5 3 2,200 $570,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 2/6/26
423 Camas St 4 3 2,577 $565,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 1/23/26
549 S Cutler Ave 3 2 2,942 $470,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 1/23/26
412 S 3rd W 3 3 1,604 $320,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 1/12/26
663 Conveyor Ave 3 3 1,596 $284,999 N/A Unknown Unknown 12/30/25
1091 Country Rd 5 3 2,835 $525,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 12/29/25
621 Jeanine Dr 3 2 1,611 $399,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 12/9/25
651 Conveyor Ave 3 3 1,596 $284,999 N/A Unknown Unknown 12/5/25
560 Austin Ave 3 2 3,274 $523,500 N/A Unknown Unknown 12/2/25
269 Hummingbird Way 3 3 1,807 $345,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 11/24/25
535 Tap Root Dr 3 3 1,596 $279,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 11/14/25
571 S Teton Ave 5 3 2,200 $535,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/24/25
657 Conveyor Ave 3 3 1,596 $299,999 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/23/25
330 S 5000 E 6 4 4,210 $570,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/17/25
554 S Austin Ave 3 2 3,274 $469,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/6/25
607 S Teton Ave 6 4 2,200 $565,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/2/25
540 Cutler Ave 7 4 3,085 $475,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 10/1/25
10 E 3rd S 4 3 2,686 $425,000 N/A Unknown Unknown 9/12/25
Average: 4.0 2.8 2,247 $445,822 $0 $0 N/A day
Viewing 1 - 40 of 40
Viewing 1 - 40 of 40